October 15, 2010

It's ALIVE!

Thousands of horns have heralded the impending death of classical music. And it's hard not to appreciate that there are many issues facing the genre: audiences that are getting both smaller and older, a population whose attention spans may be shrinking to the point that a 15-minute piece of music (let alone a 2-hour concert) is simply too long to follow, an old-fashioned and stuffy concert hall experience that turns off a younger generation, to name a few. As a lover of classical music (and a member of the classical music "industry"), I hope with all of my hopes that classical music doesn't die.


Occasionally there are glimmers of hope. There is the oft-cited popularity of (le) Poisson Rouge in NYC, which regularly programs contemporary classical music in a bar/lounge setting. There is the success of the Met Opera's live HD broadcast program. And then there is the following YouTube clip that I came across this morning. It features a 3-year old conducting the final movement of Beethoven's famous 5th Symphony.




Here is a child who hasn't yet learned that classical music is stuffy, that classical music is for old people. He is physically engaged with this music, grinning the whole time as he wiggles around. He occasionally claps, and laughs, and at one particularly adorable moment exclaims, "It's my favorite part!" as the symphony accelerates into its final, triumphant moments. What a contrast to the typical classical music experience! I'm not sure where to go with this, but I'm pretty sure that the classical music world can learn something from Jonathan.

Beethoven - Symphony No. 5: IV. Allegro (YSI)
Beethoven - Piano Concerto No. 4: II. Andante con moto (YSI)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

June 11, 2010

Eff You, Texas School Board

Last month, the Texas School Board passed a new, substantially revised history & social studies curriculum that will affect all of the state's public schools, with the potential to affect public schools across our great nation. As one of the two biggest textbook consumers in the country (the other being California), it is possible that textbook publishers will be economically compelled to reflect Texas's new curriculum in its nationally-distributed books. That said, there are some, including Robert Scott, Texas's Commissioner of Education, who believe that this is less of an issue than many people think due to the rise of desktop publishing and other technologies. Let us hope that Mr. Scott is correct, and that this travesty does not expand beyond Texas's borders.

The school board's decisions very clearly reflect a religious, political, and racial agenda. The Republicans on the school board may deny such a claim, explaining that they are merely correcting for a liberal bias. Texas democrats call it like it is, describing the recent changes as an effort to "whitewash" history. Indeed, Texas Republicans have left their dirty little fingerprints on everything from the Civil War, to the Constitution, to music.

Yes, folks, music. The school board voted to strike hip-hop from a list of "culturally significant movements" and replace it with country & western.

Please excuse me while I vomit.

Look, Texas, feel free to add country & western music to the list. It has certainly exerted its influence over the years. Elvis, for example, was clearly influenced by country music, and he in turn influenced lots of early rock n' rollers, including the Beatles, and they... well, they pretty much influenced everybody. At one point, country & western music (and folk music) filled a similar role to that of hip-hop. Look at Johnny Cash, for example. You can easily draw connections between his brand of outlaw country and gangsta rap. So why does Cash's genre deserve the attention of our country's young people, while gangsta rap does not? The answer is obvious: Cash is white.

It's hard for me to think of a musical movement that has been more culturally relevant than hip-hop over the last 30 years. Has any movement, musical or otherwise, done more to shed light on the tragedy that is our nation's inner cities? While television was taking baby steps, displaying black families in a typically white, middle-class milieu (The Cosby Show, Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, etc.), Public Enemy was releasing incisive tracks like "9-1-1 is a Joke." 2Pac was expressing the despair of a people in tracks like "Changes." Wu-Tang was rapping about urban violence and H.I.V. in tracks like "Tearz." Biggie was spitting rhymes about the "Everyday Struggles" that his community faced. The list goes on--can you think of a more genuine, charismatic tribute to one's mother than 2Pac's "Dear Mama"? And yet Texas thinks that these songs do not a significant cultural movement make.

Wow.

I know that not all hip-hop has been culturally relevant--over the past decade, much of it has focused to the glorification of violence, wealth, bling, etc. Frankly, I think we may have just seen mainstream hip-hop's own hair-metal/glam-rock phase, which I hope will soon be left behind in favor of a more expressive, relevant form.

So, why, Texas School Board, did you decide to not only add country & western, but remove hip hop from your list? Is it because hip-hop makes you uncomfortable? Is it because hip-hop's content calls into question the benefits of the capitalist--oh wait, pardon me; I understand that you've replaced the word "capitalism" with "free enterprise"--system of trickle-down economics? Or is it because you believe that this is a white, Christian country and that minorities don't belong in the story?

Whatever the reason, I have only have one more thing to say: fuck you, Texas School Board. Despite your best efforts, you've done nothing to reduce the hip-hop's relevance--you've only reduced your own.

2Pac - Dear Mama (YSI) (filesavr)
Notorious B.I.G. - Everyday Struggles (YSI) (filesavr)
Wu-Tang Clan - Tearz (YSI) (filesavr)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

June 5, 2010

Music in the Age of Obama, Part II

A year ago, I wrote about the Gershwin Prize for Popular Song being awarded to Stevie Wonder in a PBS Special. Well folks, they’ve given another award this year (though the PBS special has yet to air, I believe). The winner? Sir Paul McCartney. Not exactly earth-shattering, though some pointed out that a Brit had won an American prize.

I guess it’s always nice to see the U.S. government recognize the arts: “Here, arts! In lieu of money, we’ll give you this sweet prize!” But doesn’t it just seem completely meaningless? Here’s Paul McCartney, who at one point was the only billionaire musician (not sure where his finances stand these days) in the world, was long ago knighted by the Queen of England, loved by millions, yada yada yada. This prize doesn’t even qualify as the cherry on top of it all, it’s just superfluous. Future writers of McCartney biographies will brush over it, if they even mention it at all.

It basically seems like an excuse for a star-studded concert at the White House. And, I must admit, I would have loved to be there to see Stevie Wonder do “We Can Work it Out,” or to see McCartney charm the pants off of everyone by singing “Michelle” to the first lady. But the whole award part is boring. Why not just throw a dope concert every year that’s a celebration of music—of the art itself. Bring in young artists as well as old, doing covers as well as original songs. The concert could even tour the country (though I suppose it would have to somehow be deficit-neutral)!

But now I’m just dreaming. So here are a few great covers of McCartney songs. Enjoy!

Aretha Franklin - Eleanor Rigby (YSI) (filesavr)
Al Green - I Want to Hold Your Hand (YSI) (filesavr)
Stevie Wonder - We Can Work it Out (YSI) (filesavr)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

March 12, 2010

Food for Thought

What is the point of a concert review? If I was not at the concert, why do I care what songs they played, whether they did a sick cover of MGMT, or how charming the between-song banter was? And if I was at the concert, I already know what songs they played, what covers they did and what the banter was like. So seriously, who is the intended audience? I guess there are people out there who need the “authoritative” opinion of some music writer to confirm their own, but that doesn’t really strike me as particularly justifying.

I’m confused as to how this format has reached such prominence. I guess I can see how concert reviews might be useful for posterity’s sake. For instance, many music historians have pored through reviews of the premieres of Beethoven’s symphonies. These reviews do provide some interesting perspective on how performance practices differed in those days. For example, unlike today, it was normal back then to clap between movements. The orchestra would sometimes even repeat a movement in response to particularly rapturous applause (as in the case of the second movement of Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony).

But clearly concert reviews are not being written today purely to satisfy the interest of future historians. Why then? Clearly, there are good concert reviews written. In my experience, a review only makes for compelling reading when it’s treated as a compelling, thoughtful piece of writing—when the concert is merely a foil for the writer’s own creativity.

Well, them’s my thoughts. As always, I might be wrong. What am I missing here? Let me know.

Ray Charles – I Got a Woman (Live) (YSI) (dropbox)
James Brown – I Don’t Mind (Live) (YSI) (dropbox)
Beethoven – Symphony No. 7, Mvmt. 2 – Allegretto (YSI) (dropbox)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

March 6, 2010

J.S. Cooke

Last week, a friend of mine sent me a short essay, entitled “Hearing the Notes That Aren’t Played,” by David Mamet, the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of Glengarry Glen Ross. The essay concerns what makes for good writing, and draws upon Mamet’s experience playing the piano to illustrate his ideas. While Mamet is a writer, he draws upon a variety of different arts to demonstrate the application of his ideas.

The primary insight he offers comes from Joel Silver, who produced several of Mamet’s wife’s (Rebecca Pidgeon) records. Joel tells Mamet “Leave out the third—we hear it anyway.” Silver is referring to the third as part of a triad, the three-note chord that is the fundamental building block of all Western music, from Bach to the Beatles to the Beta Band to Beirut. The three tones that make up a triad are the first, the third, and the fifth. Of these, the third is the note that can change, becoming either major or minor and providing the color of the chord.

Mamet argues that in music as well as writing, the human ability to extrapolate and contextualize renders the third unnecessary. “We hear it anyway.” He mentions how Chekhov removed the plot, Pinter the narration, and Becket the characterization. He goes on to write a particularly beautiful paragraph about Bach’s music:

It is in our nature to elaborate, estimate, predict—to run before the event. This is the meaning of consciousness; anything else is instinct. Bach allows us to run before, and his resolutions, as per Aristotle, are as inevitable (as they must be, given the strictures of Western compositional form) and surprising as his elaborate genius. We are thus delighted and instructed, as per Freud, in a nonverbal way, as to the varieties of perception, possibility, completion—we are made better.
Obviously Bach did not always (or even often) leave out the third. But his music does travel in such a way as to require the listener’s mind to develop expectations that are either confirmed or surprised by what comes next. Therein lies the charm.

But beyond chords and harmonies, I feel that this maxim can be similarly applied to lyrics. Take Bruce Springsteen, for example. His lyrics are often so detailed, his descriptions so lush, that little is left to the imagination. Compare this to soul music, where the lyrics are often as simple as can be. “I love you I love you I love you I love you I love you I love you I love you,” for example (from Sam Cooke’s “For Sentimental Reasons). Pretty much everything is left to the imagination. Plus, Sam’s wonderful voice ensures that pretty much any thoughts you have will be beautiful ones.

Below is some Bach and some Cooke. If you listen to the Bach all the way through (both pieces), you'll get to experience one of the more famous deceptive cadences of all time (talk about upending expectations). It's also one of the more intense classical pieces I know of; I always thought it could be turned into a great hip-hop beat by someone more talented than I. Enjoy.

J.S. Bach – Passacaglia & Fugue in C Minor - Passacaglia (YSI) (dropbox)
J.S. Bach - Passacaglia & Fugue in C Minor - Fugue (YSI) (dropbox)
Sam Cooke – (I Love You) For Sentimental Reasons (YSI) (dropbox)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

January 15, 2010

You Get What You Pay For

In my post two weeks ago, I laid out a couple of predictions for the future. Today, I’d like to return to prediction number two, which stated:

“Remixes and mash-ups will fall from popularity, and we’ll look back at them as a pleasant enough yet insignificant fad.”
Several commenters cried out that this is utter foolishness, and they may be right. Regardless, I’ve been thinking recently about why remixes and mash-ups have become so abundant. Why now? What forces are behind this trend?

The most obvious answer is technological innovation, which has made it possible for every Joe Schmo with a computer and an internet connection to create his or her own product. The music world has thus been flooded with remixes and mash-ups, some of which are good, very few of which are great, and most of which are utterly forgettable.

But another reason, I think, has to do with money. Remixes and mashups are cheap—it costs nothing (or at least very little) to create a remix or mash-up. Almost everyone has a computer already, and beyond that, all you need is some software and digital music files. And, when your average consumer pays nothing for recorded music, it’s no surprise that the world will be filled by cheap products. Why pay for studio time, instruments, production, marketing, etc. when there’s no money to be made by it?

Back in the early days of file sharing, when we were downloading tracks from Napster, it was easy to think that we were doing no harm, that the music industry would continue as it always had. But that clearly isn’t the case. I believe that we’re now seeing the results of our piracy. If we, the listeners, aren't paying for music, then who is? In short, we are getting what we pay for. (Side note: this isn't happening in all industries. Look at the film industry, for example: Avatar, the most expensive movie ever made, is shaping up to be potentially the most lucrative movie ever made as well. It’s pretty impossible to imagine this phenomenon happening in music anytime soon.)

I know that there are many counter-arguments. Some will argue that live music is doing better than ever, and that may be true. Don’t get me wrong, live music is great. But if the only way a band can make money is to tour, the result is less time in the studio, and less time writing songs. Others will argue that art shouldn’t be about money, that great music will be made whether there’s money in it or not. And on some level, I agree with that. But it can’t be a good thing that we, the listening public, have removed all financial incentive for an artist to devote him- or herself to the recording studio. Many will point to how bloated and inefficient the record industry had become before its demise, and that's a good point. But if a leaner, more efficient record industry emerges in the future (or if bands increasingly adopt the In Rainbows model), will we be ready to pay up?

Here's what it boils down to: If we value great recordings, if we value the album as a musical format, then we have to show that by exchanging value of one form (money) for another (whether it’s a CD, mp3, or LP). Folks, it’s time that we pay up—if we don’t, we’ll just be left with a world of increasingly cheap and unsatisfying music. And that is not a world in which I want to live.

The Beatles - A Day in the Life (YSI) (dropbox)
Neil Young - Words (Between the Lines of Age) (YSI) (dropbox)
Pink Floyd - Money (YSI) (dropbox)

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

May 22, 2009

Get Thee to a Record Player!

This past weekend I had the pleasure of sitting with some friends and listening to records—yes, LPs, on a record player. Rarely do I find myself sitting around with people just listening to music, but it’s something I wish that I did more often. It was such a pleasant experience (it didn’t hurt that we were listening to Otis Redding), and it got me thinking about vinyl.

Over the past year, there have been a slew of articles about the reemergence of vinyl as a musical format. Publications such as the Washington Times, the Los Angeles Times, the Guardian, and even the Wall Street Journal have featured articles about the increase in popularity of record players and their accessories. While the sales figures of practically every other form of physical music format have crashed in recent years, LP sales have increased.

So, why vinyl? Who are these people buying LPs? Well, some are audiophiles—people who pride themselves on listening to only the highest quality audio. LPs are attractive to audiophiles because, unlike digital formats like the CD or mp3, LPs produce analog sound, i.e. the vibrating sound wave of the original sound is replicated precisely in the grooves of a record, without any sort of approximation. Digital media, on the other hand, rely on 16-bit binary approximations of these same sound waves. Granted, it is a very detailed approximation, and these approximations are typically made 44,100 times per second, so the real difference in sound quality between the two formats is pretty negligible. I’d bet that many “audiophiles” can’t really tell the difference—it may be simply a matter of principle, and I respect that.

Others, I imagine, simply enjoy the rituals involved with playing an LP: the careful placement of the record on the player, the lining up of the needle to the outermost groove, the warm, fuzzy sound that then proceeds to emerge from the speakers. Furthermore, I find that listening to LPs places more emphasis on the concept of a full album (of course, singles are released as records as well, but let’s push that to the side for now). It’s a bit of a process to skip songs, and there’s certainly no way to listen on shuffle, so it’s easiest just to sit back and let the album play through. And that’s wonderful. While it does seem that people still place value in the album concept, this whole iPod shuffle culture has me a bit worried.

The rising interest in vinyl may be a flash in the pan, a last-ditch effort to reclaim a technology of the past before physical music formats go the way of the dinosaurs. But I want in. I want a record player, and I want to listen to songs such as those below on LP.

The Beatles – When I Saw Her Standing There (YSI) (filesavr)
Elton John – Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters (YSI) (filesavr)
Otis Redding – Wonderful World (YSI) (filesavr)

I'm excited just thinking about it. Enjoy, and feel free to share your own thoughts on vinyl.

Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter

April 10, 2009

iPod Nation

We live in a world where iPods are ubiquitous. People use them to provide a soundtrack to a whole range of everyday activities, from working out to walking down the street. The idea is appealing—why not have a soundtrack to one’s life? For decades music has played in every restaurant, store, bar, etc. and the iPod phenomenon seems a natural extension. Yet I wonder if this is problematic. Are we becoming so used to having music in the background of our lives that we are in effect relegating music to the background? And, by having music as a constant presence, are we coming to ignore the music of the world around us—chirping birds, humming automobiles, distant conversations?

This past summer there was an article in The Atlantic about how Google and the internet are affecting our brains. In essence, the immediate availability of thousands of sources of information is reshaping our brains in a way that is shortening our attention spans. The article focuses on reading, but I wonder if the same thing isn’t happening with music. Are we losing our ability to really focus on music, to really listen hard? Might we no longer be able to listen through a complete album, or give a challenging track the multiple listens required in order to appreciate its complexities? Why give a difficult song or piece or album an hour of your time when with The Hype Machine you can sample 30 tracks in the same time period in order to find a track that is immediately pleasing?

I don’t know the answer to these questions, but I am a little worried. To many, listening to music is no longer a primary activity, but a sideshow, a soundtrack, to other activities. No longer do people gather around a record or CD player and listen through an entire album. Furthermore, a generation is growing used to music being free—i..e. without value. Value in its most basic sense is what one is willing to exchange for a good or service (or such is my layman’s understanding). And many are unwilling to exchange anything for recorded music.

Granted, live music is doing extremely well, and that is wonderful. But I do wonder about the future of recorded music. Many suggest that music will soon become a service rather than a product, where one pays a fee as part of their internet subscription and can then have access to any music they want. In essence, it will become a utility, like electricity, the internet, and water. And while utilities are certainly valuable, and it would be hard to imagine life without them, lumping music into the same category seems unjust to something as interesting, diverse and powerful as music.

Anyways, these are some of my thoughts and concerns. I am making no attempt to fight iPods or free music downloading—it would be a pointless fight at this point, and I’ve offered up many free tracks on this very blog. And I’m not going to stop (see below). Call me a hypocrite, but there are certainly benefits as well as costs to the ready availability of music (perhaps a topic for another post). I just think we need to think hard about and be aware of how technology is affecting our relationship with music. In truth, I know that people value music, and I have faith that people will always value music. After all, many claim that music evolved before language. I’m just trying to spark some thought and discussion. My worries may be misplaced, or totally off base, and if so, tell me. Leave a comment.

And here are a couple long tracks off of great albums that deserve a good, focused listen. Listen, and then go buy the albums.

Isaac Hayes - Hyperbolicsyllablecsesquedalymistic (YSI) (filesavr)
Fela Kuti - Sorrow Tears and Blood (YSI) (filesavr)


Bookmark Digg Bookmark Del.icio.us Share on Facebook Bookmark Reddit Bookmark StumbleUpon Bookmark Technorati Bookmark Twitter